Try a free reading, no card required Start now

A Taurus has gone quiet, and why pushing at it sets it

Nine days. His jumper is still over the back of your chair and you haven't moved it. On Tuesday you asked whether the parcel had turned up and he answered inside the hour, perfectly pleasant, like a man with nothing at all wrong. Then you sent the other one, the message that took you forty minutes to write, and it's been sitting there since. He's answering the small things. He isn't answering you.

Bring his birthday and the last six months

Not the nine days. His date, roughly when things went flat, and what the two of you stopped doing. Stella reads Venus before she reads the sun on a Taurus, because Venus rules him. Someone is on now whatever your clock says, and your first 200 credits are free with no card.

Ask a reader now(200 FREE credits, no card needed)

Readers are online 24/7. No subscription.

A real reading looks like this

bryn, 2 may 1989. hes been quiet 9 days. he still replies if its something practical but nothing else. we havent even had a row. is he done with me
Stella. Nine days, and I think you've been counting the wrong number, so let me start there rather than where you asked me to. From that date his sun sits at eleven degrees of Taurus and his Venus at eighteen, in Taurus as well. Venus rules his sign, so she's his chart ruler as well as his love planet, and she's at home in the least movable sign on the wheel. A man built that way doesn't go quiet in a week. He goes quiet at the end of something that has been getting heavier for a long stretch, and the nine days is only the part with a date on it. So tell me about the last few months instead of the last fortnight. When did it stop being easy?
honestly since about february. he stopped suggesting things. i put it down to work being mad
February to now. That's the shape I was expecting and it changes what the nine days are. A fixed sign doesn't hold a position it arrived at on a whim, it holds one it walked towards slowly, so by the time the quiet starts most of the deciding is already behind him. Now hear the other half before you do anything with that, because on its own it's cruel and it isn't accurate. Fixed cuts both ways. He's exactly as slow to close a door as he is to open one, and slow is not the same as final. What I won't do is tell you how his evenings are going or where his attention has landed. That's not delicacy. Nine days of nothing has a length and no contents, so whatever I painted into it would be mine rather than his, and you'd be carrying it around by Thursday. Tell me what you've sent him since it started.
three. one asking if hes ok, one just saying i miss you, and one on sunday saying can we please talk
All three are fair and all three do the same job on him, which is to ask a man who has stopped moving to move. That's the part nobody warns you about with this sign, and I'm glad you asked me before the fourth. Fixed earth answers pressure by weighing more. It isn't a sulk and it isn't aimed at you, it's the whole function of the modality, and you happen to be leaning on the one sign that was built to be leaned on. Nothing you've sent has ruined anything, by the way, and I'd like you to stop rereading them tonight. One thing I can't settle without an hour. His moon crossed out of Pisces that afternoon, so he's a Pisces moon or an Aries moon and those two sit inside a silence very differently. That would tell me what holding this costs him. It wouldn't tell me whether he ends it, which I suspect is the real question. What was the last completely ordinary thing you two did together, with nothing riding on it?

A Taurus going quiet has usually already decided something, and that's the honest opening even if it isn't the kind one. Fixed signs don't drift out of contact. They arrive at a position and stop moving, and the quiet you're looking at is what a taken position looks like from outside. With this sign the deciding nearly always happened long before the silence did, so what you're watching is the tail of something rather than the front of it.

Which cuts the other way too, and that half matters just as much.

Fixed earth, and what those two words do to a man

Taurus is fixed and it's earth, and between them you have most of him.

Fixed is the modality of the middle of a season. Not beginning, not turning over into the next thing. Holding. A fixed sign's work is keeping something going once it exists, which is why the same man gets called reliable by one half of his life and immovable by the other. Same machinery, two ends of it.

Earth means it all happens in the practical. What he concludes shows up in what he arranges rather than in what he announces.

Put them together and a silence stops being weather. It's a position, in the physical sense of the word. He has moved to a spot and stopped, and the quiet is the shape of him standing there.

Which is why nine days is the wrong number

You're combing the last fortnight for the sentence that did it. There generally isn't one.

A cardinal sign can decide inside an afternoon and a mutable one is somewhere else entirely by Wednesday. Fixed does neither. It accumulates over months and then stops all at once, and the stopping is the first part anybody else can see.

So what will actually help you is the boring stretch before the quiet. When the suggesting stopped. When you last made a plan that wasn't logistics. The answer you're hunting for in the read receipts is back there, and it's more likely to be a slow flattening than an incident.

Pressure is the one input that makes it heavier

Here's the useful and unwelcome part, and then the other half of it.

Fixed means resistance. Not as an insult, as a definition. Lean on a fixed sign and it doesn't move, it sets, because holding under load is what the modality does. So the natural response to being ignored, more contact and longer explanations and the message that finally makes him understand, is the one input that reliably makes a Taurus silence denser.

Now the other half, because women take that sentence and turn it into evidence against themselves by four in the morning. The messages you've already sent have not ruined this. Three texts in nine days is not a campaign. A fixed sign that was going to reopen doesn't get permanently shut by someone being frightened at it, and one that had already decided was never going to be talked out of it by your silence either.

The arrangements keep running, and that misleads people

An earth sign keeps its arrangements running long past the point where the feeling has changed. He'll still pay his half. He'll still drop the thing round, still answer about the parcel inside the hour, still turn up for what was already in the diary. Most people read that as proof he's still in it.

It isn't proof. Continuing is cheap for him, it's the default state of the whole sign.

The signal with weight in it runs the other way. When an earth sign starts dismantling the practical, when his things come back and the standing arrangements quietly stop, that's him doing something the sign finds expensive. The rest is the machine idling.

What tends to open it again

Not the summit meeting, which is where most advice about this sign goes wrong.

Taurus reopens through the ordinary, because the ordinary is where it lives. The reappearance, when it comes, is about the car or the bins or something one of you left at the other's, delivered flat, with no account of the nine days attached. If you were waiting for him to walk in with an explanation, you'll feel robbed.

He isn't dodging the reckoning. He genuinely thinks the resuming is the reconciliation. With a Taurus the conversation, if you want one, comes afterwards, asked for once and then left alone.

Where his sun sign stops being able to help

A sun sign is one placement out of dozens, and it describes what a man aims at rather than what he's like to be shut out by.

How he behaves when he's hurt is his moon, and behind a Taurus sun the moon can be anything. A water moon feels every hour of it. An air moon is talking about it constantly, to someone who isn't you. A fire moon makes a shorter, hotter version that breaks on its own. Same immovable surface, three different men under it, and the one that answers your question is the one nobody checks.

How Stella takes one of these apart

She'll take the months before she'll take the days, which throws people who arrived with a fortnight and a screenshot.

Then she goes to Venus rather than the sun, because Venus rules Taurus, so here it's his chart ruler as much as his love planet, and it comes off a birthday alone. Then she wants an hour, and if his moon changed sign that day she names both and refuses to pick the nicer one.

What she won't do is fill the gap in, for the reason this page has been making all the way down: a silence has a duration and nothing inside it, so any detail about how he's spending it would have come out of her rather than out of him. With this sign the pull to be handed something concrete is enormous, because concrete is what he deals in and what you've been starved of. That's the point where a reading turns into fiction, and fiction is the sort of thing people act on.

Take the months, not the nine days

If he ended it out loud, that's a different situation with a different clock, and whether he turns up again has its own answer.

Bring his date, whatever anyone remembers about the hour, and the honest version of when it went flat. Ask about the stretch you've been ignoring rather than the nine days you've read forty times.

What people said after theirs

★★★★★

I had eleven days and a theory for every one of them. She spent almost none of the reading on the eleven days and kept dragging me back to the previous autumn, which annoyed me until I realised I could actually answer her. He surfaced in the end, over something to do with the car, exactly as unceremoniously as she said he would.

Alaw, verified reading
★★★★★

What I wanted was permission to send a long message explaining myself. She wouldn't give it and she wouldn't tell me not to either, she just explained what that kind of message does to a fixed sign and left it with me. I sent it anyway. She was right about what came back, which was nothing.

Eimear, verified reading
★★★★★

Mine was the less hopeful version and I'd still rather have had it. She said with him the quiet had probably been the last stage rather than the first, and that I should think about what had changed at Christmas. Something had. She didn't know what it was and said so, which I trusted her more for.

Morvoren, verified reading

Still turning it over?

That is what the readers are for. First reading is free.

Ask a reader now(200 FREE credits, no card needed)

Readers are online 24/7. No subscription.

Questions people ask us

Why has my Taurus man gone quiet?

Because he's arrived somewhere and stopped, and the silence is what that looks like from outside. Taurus is a fixed sign, so it holds positions rather than moods, and a position takes it a long time to reach. That's why the trigger you're hunting for in last week usually isn't there. Look at the last few months instead, where things went flat rather than wrong.

How long does a Taurus stay silent?

Longer than almost any other sign, and any figure you get handed has been picked rather than read. Fixed earth doesn't burn off the way fire does, because there's no heat in it to burn. It changes when the conditions around it change, not when a certain number of days have gone by. Weeks is ordinary here, which is worth knowing before you read week three as an answer.

Is a Taurus silence a punishment?

Rarely in the way it feels. Punishment needs someone watching to see whether it's landing, and this sign mostly isn't watching, it's just stopped. What people read as a strategy is usually a man who has run out of anything he's willing to say and won't perform a conversation he isn't ready for. It's still doing damage to you, and both of those can be true.

Should I keep texting a Taurus who is ignoring me?

Nobody who hasn't met the two of you should be writing you a rule about that. What's worth knowing first is the mechanism: pressure is the single input that makes a fixed sign heavier, because resistance is what fixed means. Volume works on some signs and this is the wrong one for it. That isn't a reason to feel guilty about the messages you've already sent.

What makes a Taurus start talking again?

Usually the ordinary resuming rather than the big conversation happening. This sign reopens through routine, through the small practical thing that used to just occur between you, and it tends to arrive with no preamble and no account of where he's been. That can be maddening if you wanted the reckoning first. With a Taurus the reckoning, if it comes at all, comes after.

Is it his Taurus sun or is it me?

Both questions are real and the sun sign only reaches so far into either. A sun describes what a man is organised around, not what he does at midnight when something has hurt him, and that second one belongs to his moon. Two men with the same Taurus sun and different moons produce silences you wouldn't recognise as the same behaviour. If his birth time exists anywhere, that's the placement worth the awkward ask.

People reading this also asked